Newsletters Select newsletters below and click the button to sign up!
Internetnews BloggersRecent Entries
ArchivesMonthly ArchivesSearch The Blog
« Display ads still engaging, study says |
Michelle Megna Blog
| Will HTC Hero hamper myTouch sales? »
Now you see iPorn, now you don't, but maybe you willIt appears the "Hottest Girls" are not. But maybe they are. Earlier today the "Hottest Girls" app was being touted as the first iTunes/iPhone app approved by Apple to show full nudity, promising there'd be a lot more skin seen on iPhone screens. But by mid-day on the East Coast, it seemed the app had simply slipped past the Apple censors, and it was removed from the App store. By late afternoon, however, the developer Allen Leung, said in a blog post that the app was just temporarily unavailable due to demand. "The server usage is extremely high because of the popularity of this app. Thus, by not distributing the app, we can prevent our servers from crashing. Those who already have the app will still be able to use our app. To answer the question on everyone's mind: Yes, the topless images will still be there when it is sold again." With Apple not responding to invitations to comment, we're left to speculate on the veracity of Leung's claims as well as what happened at the App Store approval office today. The "Hottest Girls" app at issue was already on sale at the Apple App Store and offered photos of women in lingerie. But with an update, "Hottest Girls" showed pictures of topless and naked women. When Leung told the Macenstein blog he uploaded naked pictures in an update to the app today, most industry watchers believed the move was authorized by Apple in a nod to its recent parental controls built into the iPhone SDK 3.0. But by mid-day, "Hottest Girls" was already removed from the App store, according to blog posts and other reports. This left industry watchers wondering whether Apple had inadvertently let the update go through and then banned it, or, as Leung says, authorized it but removed it temporarily at his request. The brouhaha over the bare-chested babes at the app store isn't surprising given that controversy had erupted over Apple's iPhone app approval process, which critics charged was inconsistent, confusing and based on arbitrary criteria. At issue, basically, was the fact that some content deemed 'mature' was already available for iTunes, and the iPhone could access that material through its Web browser. The approval of "Hottest Girls" was unthinkable a few months back, when Apple initially blocked an e-book app from the same store because it could access the Kama Sutra. The company later reversed the decision, but it had also come under fire for other app approval flaps, including one involving explicit lyrics in a song by Nine Inch Nails, which it also later approved. In that case, Nine Inch Nails called Apple's content evaluation process nothing less than capricious. In his band Web site forum, frontman Trent Reznor accused Apple of using a double-standard -- the company had rejected an update to the band's iPhone app, while the song featured in the app was available for sale on iTunes. Eventually, Apple relented. So, the thinking went, why would Apple start allowing porn at the App store? It seemed plausible the reason is because parental controls are included in the iPhone 3.0 SDK that allow users to block applications rated by certain ages, for instance 12, or 17 or older. At least one blogger, however, thought that Leung inadvertently gamed the system. The reasoning was that Leung is pulling the nude pictures from an online directory, so in essence, he hasn't really provided a pornographic app but rather uploaded adult content as an update to an existing app that was already approved -- and Apple simply missed it. But now that Leung is countering that premise, and with no word from Apple, it's too soon to tell whether the "Hottest Girls" are gone for good or just playing hard to get. 0 TrackBacksListed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Now you see iPorn, now you don't, but maybe you will. TrackBack URL for this entry: https://swarm.jupitermedia.com/mt-tb.cgi/8360 |
||
Leave a comment