Newsletters

Select newsletters below and click the button to sign up!

Boston News NY News
DC News Internet Daily
SiliconValley News
InternetNews Business Report




Become a Marketplace Partner



Partner With Us















Internetnews Bloggers

Recent Entries

Archives

January 2009
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31

Monthly Archives

Search The Blog

Solidly Stated by Judy Mottl (bio)

Storage insights and other bits from the Web



When a story isn't a story

Jim Balsille, and likely his top sales team, must have been suffering some serious palipitations last week when a tech news site ran a big headline, and big story, about how a big Research in Motion (RIM) customer was considering switching off the BlackBerry platform for Apple's new iPhone.

A tech leader at HSBC, the world's biggest bank, was quoted in a story as saying the company was thinking about moving thousands of users off BlackBerries to the iPhone.

This would be big news, and, like most other tech reporters I suspect, I jumped on the phone to get details.

But the news was that it wasn't news at all. It wasn't true.

As one person I called, who asked to remain anonymous, told me "there's not a snowball's chance in hell" it was happening.

I could almost hear the sigh of collective relief at RIM, and likely within HSBC's compliance division since there's no comparison yet to be made between the iPhone's security abilities and the BlackBerry, though Apple has done a better job on its firmware 2.0 and will likely keep improving on that moving forward.

I'm not naming the publication that ran the story because the purpose of my blog is not to take cheap shots.

No one is perfect, and no publication is immune from having to correct itself now and then.

We're human.

The problem is the fact that so many Web sites took the story and ran with it, repeating the erroneous news all over the Internet, from blogs to publications, and so few took the time to make two quick calls to verify whether it was actually happening.

The lesson from this is that we -- all in the tech industry, those who create news and those who report on news -- all need to keep a skeptical eye.

We also have to fight the urge to jump on a bandwagon. We can't let the very competitive pace of online journalism let us los track of the need to verify and doublecheck before we put words to Web pages.

Yea, I'm being preachy. I'm allowed.

But I respect my industry and colleagues who follow the golden rule of getting information first-hand -- the old fashion way.

After all, it's still amazing how powerful the written word can be, even when it's not on paper.

| Comments (1) | TrackBacks (0) | Share

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: When a story isn't a story.

TrackBack URL for this entry: https://swarm.jupitermedia.com/mt-tb.cgi/4420

1 Comments

Simon said:

As one of the blogs that hopped on the bandwagon, I can say this happens pretty often. Writing articles quickly is a big part of what we do, and it's often faster to throw in a grain-of-salt disclaimer than double-check information. Sometimes that information isn't readily verifiable. For example, I don't have any contacts at HSBC, so double-checking this story would involve a day or two of e-mails to get to someone who knows something, after which point the news is old. For better or worse, citing other news sources shifts responsibility for quality information to the original author.

To be fair, a big part of the original story was simply spinning the CIO's words. He was saying that they hadn't ruled the iPhone out as possible platform - however, not saying no doesn't mean yes.

Leave a comment